No. Its not an effective form of risk vs reward. There isn't much risk in spamming combinations of q1 mats to find all the recipes but there is a huge reward for it. Not to mention it would greatly skew the risk vs reward for combat when you end up with only a select few face rolling everyone with massive gear advantages. Its not much of a 'risk' in that case. People would literally be forced to endure the tedium of trial and error if they even wanted a chance to compete. Then there is also the fact that such a system would greatly reward people for hacking/data mining the information and then keeping it to themselves. Or getting insider information from team members, which is next to impossible to prove or prevent.