If you PvP in lawful you should go red and drop everything. No loss except time if newbies get killed and all risk for attackers seems fine to me. Yes losing shitty goblin gear has made lots of people quit, it's stupid but I've experienced it first hand a few times. This doesn't seem like something that would take much dev time. And anyone disagreeing with this topic must've never tried to get friends to play because the struggle is real. @Sero If your idea is letting them choose to fight how do you do that?